The death of “Good Job”

We watched Boyhood last night, a movie that so beautifully follows a boy growing up. Of course, we couldn’t stop thinking about Benjamin and our own parenting. It’s a movie that really makes you think about the impact of small words and conversations throughout a kid’s life. As if our parenting culture isn’t already stupidly obsessed with overthinking parenting. (Here is my preferred list.)

In reference to that first article though, the one thing I would actually take to heart is #1: “Great Job.” However true the author’s rationale may be (let’s encourage the development of internal motivation by reducing generic external praise), my real reason for trying to banish “good/great job” is this: it gets so stinking old and exhausting to constantly say it. There are times in the day where I could be tossing out a “good job” (or the lazier version: “goooood”) every 30 seconds and it becomes a bit mind numbing. It takes a bit more brainpower to think of specific affirmations, but it’s way more fun!

As with any toddler, Ben is making leaps and bounds in development every single day. Today he found John’s tennis rackets and decided to take up the sport.

NOTE: You did not catch me saying “Good Job” in that video. (Oops!) Oh, and to explain Ben’s immediate fall from happiness into a tantrum:  well… 1. he is a toddler, but 2. he is battling double ear infections (sad!) and has been falling apart at the drop of a hat all weekend. Poor guy!)

This was at 6 months old (ish): Right-handed Baby Federer

photo 2 (41)

And here he is now at almost 20 months: Lefty Toddler Nadal?


We’ll see which hand he picks as time goes on, but I think secretly John is praying that he is left-handed (and 6’3″ of course). That would certainly help him meet our expectation of winning at least a few Grand Slams in his career.  haha!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s